Dude this totally an unfair question, I mean how can you compare two perfect Idols from back in the day. as far as combat? I gotta put my money on murray, He's way bigger. another good question is which mascot has been drawn by fans more. I know my folders from the day we're covered with both.
Well, I know this wasn't mentioned, but what about Vic Rattlehead from Megadeth? He's my personal favourite mascot. But on topic with this question, I'd have to say I love both, but in combat, I'm going to put my money on Murray. He seems more intimidating.
They are both great! i remenber when i first saw the Murray on the Last in line live video, thats was cool. But Eddie was out of this world! both are great. but i'll stick to my man RJD and choose MURRAY